A deer may be startled by a loud noise and take
off through the forest, but as soon as the threat is gone, the deer immediately
calms down and starts grazing. And it does not appear to be in anxiety about it
later. Let us playact for a moment that we are that deer, living in the
grasslands of India. We have slim long feet that help us get into a sprint
quickly and pruned senses that pick up signs of danger, a majestic antelope
that grabs attention from the group of humans that, every now and then, come driving around on a jungle expedition taking
pictures of us.
Perhaps the biggest difference between us and our other deer friends, and the
humans taking our photograph is that nearly every decision we make (as a
deer) provides an immediate benefit to our life. When we are hungry, we
walk over and chomp on a bush. When it rains, we shelter under a tree. When we
spot a tiger, we run away. Most of our choices as a deer—like what to eat or
where to sleep or when to avoid a predator—make an immediate impact on our
life. We live in what scientists call an immediate-return environment
because our actions instantly deliver clear and immediate outcomes.
Now, let’s flip the script and pretend we are one of the humans on the jungle expedition. While taking photographs from the Jeep, we might think, “This safari has been a lot of fun. It would be cool to work as a park ranger and see deer every day. Speaking of work, is it time for a career change? Am I really doing the work I was meant to do? Should I change jobs?”
Most of the choices we make today
will not benefit us immediately. If we do a good job at
work today, we will get a recognition at the end of the business quarter. If we
save money now, we will have enough for retirement later. Many aspects of
modern society are designed to delay rewards until some point in the future. This
is true of our problems as well. Such a
situation is commonly referred to as
Researching hunting and gathering societies, anthropologist James
Woodburn classified societies into two major categories: those with
immediate return systems and those with delayed return systems. This entails
two different environments.
The Immediate Return Environment
In an Immediate Return Environment, the actions of an individual bring about immediate benefits. Everything that prehistoric humans did was oriented at the present, as a result of following their instincts to survive: avoiding predators, finding shelter when they need it, reproducing, hunting and gathering to survive. For the sole purpose of completing these tasks, they made tools and weapons that did not require a lot of labour. The human brain evolved in this type of environment to use anxiety to protect humans from danger and starvation, compelling them to solve all the short-term problems they were faced with. The feelings of stress and anxiety were relieved as each problem was solved.
The Delayed Return Environment
The actions taken in a Delayed Return Environment
are not directed at an immediate benefit, but with future reward in mind. Each
day we work, we are putting in the effort to get a reward in the future: salary
at the end of the month/project. We study in order to obtain a degree in years.
We save money so we can invest it or enjoy spending it later.
We choose healthy foods and exercise knowing that it will not make us fit immediately, but in the future and only if we maintain a regimen, and so on.
As humans evolved, they adopted more
characteristics of delayed return societies, making elaborate weapons, processing,
and storing food for future use, etc. But the modern environment presents a
very abrupt change when you look at it from the perspective of evolution. The
Delayed Return Environment tends to lead to chronic stress and anxiety for
humans. Why? Because the human brain did not evolve for
life in a delayed-return environment.
Evolution of the Brain
The earliest remains of modern humans, known as
Homo sapiens, are approximately two hundred thousand years old. These were the
first humans to have a brain relatively like ours. In particular, the
neocortex—the newest part of the brain and the region responsible for higher
functions like language—was roughly the same size two hundred thousand years
ago as today. Compared to the age
of the brain, modern society is incredibly new. It is only
recently—during the last 500 years or so—that our society has shifted to a
predominantly Delayed Return Environment.
The pace of change has increased exponentially compared to prehistoric times. In the last 100 years we have seen the rise of the car, the airplane, the television, the personal computer, the Internet, and MTV. Nearly everything that makes up our daily life has been created in a very small window of time. From the perspective of evolution, however, 100 years is nothing. The modern human brain spent hundreds of thousands of years evolving for one type of environment (immediate returns) and in the blink of an eye the entire environment changed (delayed returns).
The Evolution of Anxiety
The mismatch between our old brain and our new environment
has a significant impact on the amount of chronic stress and anxiety we
experience today. Thousands of years ago, when humans lived in an
Immediate Return Environment, stress and anxiety were useful emotions because
they helped us take action in the face of immediate problems.
Examples:
Anxiety was an emotion that helped protect humans in an Immediate Return Environment. It was built for solving short-term, acute problems. There was no such thing as chronic stress because there are not really chronic problems in an Immediate Return Environment. Wild animals rarely experience chronic stress. Today we face different problems. Will I have enough money to pay the bills next month? Will I get the promotion at work or remain stuck in my current job? Will I repair my broken relationship? Problems in a Delayed Return Environment can rarely be solved right now in the present moment.
Ways to balance our Anxiety and Stress.
One of the greatest sources of
anxiety in a Delayed Return Environment is the constant uncertainty.
There is no guarantee that working hard in school will get you a job. There is
no promise that investments will go up in the future. There is no assurance
that going on a date will land you a soulmate. Living in a Delayed Return
Environment means you are surrounded by uncertainty. So how do we reconcile the
way our brains work with the problems of the Delayed Return Environment?
First things first: we need to deal with the built-up chronic
stress through small lifestyle changes. Many of us have
excess levels of cortisol (the stress hormone) because of this fast-paced
environment, so adjusting our diet, sleeping habits, and exercising more is the
first step to balancing these hormones. Of course, practices such as meditation
can help us regain emotional balance and realign our thoughts; meditation takes
time to perfect, but it is worth it (there we go, delayed return all over
again).
Next, there are two ways to regain balance:
01) Measuring something: . . . . . .
. . . . We cannot know for certain how much money we
will have in retirement, but we can remove some uncertainty from the situation
by measuring how much we save each month. We cannot predict when we will find
love, but we can pay attention to how many times we introduce ourselves to
someone new.
The act of measurement takes an unknown quantity and makes it known.
When we measure something, we immediately become more certain about the
situation. Measurement will not magically solve our problems, but it will
clarify the situation, pull us out of the black box of worry and uncertainty,
and help us get a grip on what is actually happening.
Furthermore, one of the most important distinctions between an Immediate
Return Environment and a Delayed Return Environment is rapid feedback.
Animals are constantly getting feedback about the things that cause them
stress. As a result, they actually know whether or not they should feel
stressed. Without measurement you have no feedback.
02) Shift Your Worry: . . . . . . . . . . The second thing we can
do is “shift our worry” from the long-term problem to a daily routine
that will solve that problem. Instead of worrying about living longer, we
can focus on taking a walk each day. Instead of worrying about losing enough
weight for the wedding, we can focus on cooking a healthy dinner tonight.
The key insight that makes this strategy work is making sure our daily
routine both rewards you right away (immediate return) and resolves our future
problems (delayed return).
In the end, hopefully, by reflecting on the way the brain works and
acknowledging how it puts anxiety in motion, we can use these mechanisms to our
advantage. The Delayed Return Environment presents a challenge for humans, but
there is a way to reconcile the age-old hardwiring of the brain with this
environment that presents itself as threatening. Research has shown that the
ability to delay gratification is one of the primary drivers of success. It is
then interesting that delaying gratification is both the opposite of what our
brain evolved to do and the skill that matches the Delayed Return Environment
we live in today.
**Source Credits: 1) https://thriveglobal.com/stories/the-evolution-of-anxiety/. 2) History of Inequality by James Woodburn (1982) 3) The Mysteries of Human Behaviour by Mark Leary.
Content Curated By:
Dr Shoury Kuttappa.
Comments
Post a Comment